Posts tagged Supreme Court

    Commentary: New York’s Union Speech Crackdown

    November 16, 2026 // Until the NLRA is amended to make unions truly democratic and responsible to their members—proposed legislation like the Employee Rights Act would do that—it falls to the small handful of outside groups like the Freedom Foundation to do the awkward but necessary work of informing workers about what their unions neglect to tell them. New York and other states should not be afraid of workers knowing their rights.

    Op-ed: Trump’s labor panel can free workers trapped in unions they oppose

    November 16, 2026 // Especially egregious are obstacles created by the National Labor Relations Board that automatically block workers’ petitions to hold decertification elections — no matter how large a majority of workers back them. These bars, which lack statutory justification, ignore the clear language of the law, which commands that the board “shall” conduct elections whenever a question of representation exists outside a one-year period following a previous election. Our petition calls on the board to end what is known as the “successor bar”

    Supreme Court grapples with Department of Labor case involving migrant worker fines

    November 12, 2026 // Deputy Solicitor General Sarah Harris argued that because the H-2A program allowed the farm to import noncitizen workers, the government was granting a privilege via the government's immigration powers, and that therefore punishments for violating the terms of the program should be handled within the Labor Department. Robert Johnson, lawyer for Sun Valley Orchards, argued that the farm is being accused of violating a contract, creating a dispute that would have to be brought to a federal court if the federal government wanted to extract a fine out of the farm.

    Liberty Justice Center Secures Victory for Puerto Rico Worker Over Unauthorized Union Dues

    November 2, 2026 // The Liberty Justice Center (LJC) has secured a victory for public employees’ First Amendment rights in Rigau v. Quintana, securing reimbursement of improperly deducted union dues and binding commitments to prevent future unauthorized deductions from the wages of Puerto Rico Industrial Commission (PRIC) employee Luis Rigau. The agreements resolve his claims against his employer, Commission President María T. Quintana, in her official capacity, and the union, Federación Central de Trabajadores, UFCW Local 481. Rigau’s lawsuit challenged the unauthorized reinstatement of his union membership and the resumption of union dues deductions from his wages, despite his repeated written objections. The Liberty Justice Center represented Rigau alongside the National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation.

    US Supreme Court will not review Trump’s firing of labor board member

    October 20, 2026 // The justices turned away former NLRB member Gwynne Wilcox's appeal of a lower court's ruling that said the Republican president's January 2025 firing of her was a valid exercise of executive authority.

    Yale Political Union votes to ban public-sector unions after debate with Freedom Foundation CEO Aaron Withe

    October 15, 2026 // Members of the Yale Political Union voted 35-25, to pass the resolution “Ban Public-Sector Unions” after Freedom Foundation CEO Aaron Withe argued the affirmative on Sept. 29. Founded in 1934, the Yale Political Union is one of the country’s best-known student debate societies. After Withe’s opening speech, students questioned him and debated the resolution before the house voted. Withe opened by quoting President Franklin D. Roosevelt, who wrote in 1937 that collective bargaining “cannot be transplanted into the public service.” The quote, Withe noted, came not from Ronald Reagan, Ron DeSantis or Scott Walker, but from FDR.

    Keeping Workers in the Dark: The Push for Employer Neutrality in Union Campaigns

    September 30, 2026 // Whether or not one supports unionization in a particular workplace, elected officials should not pressure one party in a labor dispute to relinquish rights recognized to balance competing interests. The law recognizes rights and responsibilities for employees, unions, and employers alike. Yet calls for neutrality almost always run in one direction: in favor of organized labor. There is rarely a corresponding demand that unions remain neutral. Instead, neutrality initiatives frequently seek to silence only one side of the debate. The answer to competing claims should be more information, not less. Collective bargaining can involve difficult or protracted negotiations and may affect workplace flexibility, labor costs, wages, benefits, and business operations.

    Liberty Justice Center Sues Brooklyn Library Union Over Compulsory Dues

    September 28, 2026 // The Liberty Justice Center filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of Brooklyn Public Library employee Jeffrey A. Schwartz, challenging the requirement that he pay union dues as a condition of his employment. In Schwartz v. Brooklyn Library Guild, Local 1482, AFL-CIO et al., the Liberty Justice Center represents Schwartz, a Government Documents Librarian at the Brooklyn Public Library (BPL). The lawsuit challenges the continued deduction of union dues from his wages by BPL and Local 1482. It alleges that the arrangement is unconstitutional because the City of New York is so deeply entwined with BPL’s governance—especially with respect to employee pay and benefits—that BPL’s actions are fairly attributable to the government. As a result, the lawsuit argues, BPL employees are entitled to the same First Amendment protections as other public employees.

    Commentary: Are Unions Rising from the Political Grave?

    September 21, 2026 // Here again, however, there may be less than meets the eye. Despite its surprising bipartisan support, the FLCA would raise significant constitutional questions if enacted. By relying on a government-mandated arbitration panel to resolve labor disputes, the law effectively empowers the state to impose contractual terms on private parties—a form of what constitutional lawyers call “state action.” As attorneys Alex MacDonald and Vinnie Vernuccio observe: “[S]tate action opens the door to a slew of constitutional requirements and restrictions, notably to protect rights of free speech and association.”

    A teacher’s disagreement with WEA shows why public workers need to know their rights

    September 21, 2026 // Travis Reep, a fifth-grade teacher in Thurston County, agrees with that statement from Washington state Superintendent of Public Instruction Chris Reykdal. But in a recent Yes on Initiative 001 video, Reep says Reykdal’s actions — and those of the Washington Education Association, his union — do not match those words. Reep is a father of four, an elected local union representative and a WEA member. He disagrees with WEA’s opposition to I-001, an initiative that, among other provisions, would restore parents’ access to school-held medical and mental-health counseling records, require prior notification when medical services are offered, except in emergencies, and require notification when schools arrange treatment involving follow-up care beyond normal school hours.